Last modified: 2012-04-19 21:02:45 UTC
The "hide" function in the feedback dashboard - [[Special:FeedbackDashboard]] - does not also suppress the related entry that appears in Special:Log, so there are occasional instances of defamation, death threats, personal information/outing, etc. Regards - HF25
(In reply to comment #0) > The "hide" function in the feedback dashboard - [[Special:FeedbackDashboard]] - > does not also suppress the related entry that appears in Special:Log, so there > are occasional instances of defamation, death threats, personal > information/outing, etc. Regards - HF25 Note: This is a cross-wiki feature
(In reply to comment #1) > (In reply to comment #0) > > The "hide" function in the feedback dashboard - [[Special:FeedbackDashboard]] - > > does not also suppress the related entry that appears in Special:Log, so there > > are occasional instances of defamation, death threats, personal > > information/outing, etc. Regards - HF25 > > Note: This is a cross-wiki feature
Sorry, I'm unsure of how to modify a comment on Bugzilla - anyway, hiding is an admin-only feature and so it should automatically remove/suppress the log entry in a way like revision deletion. (The log entries look something like this: (Happy: [text here])
Log link: [[Special:Log/moodbar]] Feedback dashboard: [[Special:FeedbackDashboard]]
Assigning this to Alolita so she can find someone to fix it.
Researching options with Philippe and Oliver -- ideally, this process should mirror how oversighting happens in other areas of WP. In the short term, we may just suppress the actual comment itself and only display happy/sad/confused.
This makes sense as if you suppress the log by marking log_deleted as true, the log is still shown but with a strike through. And at this point, without changing the structure of the logging table, there is no way of suppressing a log or restoring it should the feedback be restored by an admin. It makes sense to just filter the feedback comment in the log itself. I have done this per Howie's recommendation. Fixed in trunk r112358
Upon further inspection of this and talking with Benny, it seems we can set log_deleted = 2. This will suppress the log summary. Though, it may require placing an index on log_title to update the feedback log. At this point though, the comment has been omitted on further feedback per the above fix. As to whether the log needs to be suppressed now, I'm not sure. Reopening for further review.
What's the status on this one?
I think Rob Moen fixed this already per Howie's suggestion, which removes moodbar comment from the log
I've re-closed this as it seems this is an acceptable fix.
