Last modified: 2012-09-13 05:48:40 UTC
Since for a normal image one always should use thumb to scale it, I suggest to preselected "thumb" in the format dropdown and to append it in non-dialog mode. If you need some statistics: 59 % of all images in the German Wikipedia (not counting images on discussion and user pages) use "thumb" or an equivalent parameter (that's a fact) and among the other images there are many where "thumb" is just missing because the editor didn't know of it (that's my opinion).
See patch: Gerrit change #20654
(sorry for joining late). IMO, it will be best if the defaults can be set per-project, overriding those hardcoded in the code itself. as to implementation: Personally, i would prefer setting the defaults through variables in common.js, rather than LocalSettings.php, so sysops can change it when community decides (this would also allow, possibly, for users to set different defaults for themselves, though it is not clear how valuable this is). peace.
Please make the change Kipod wrote about usable as soon as possible.
kipod, thumb is used almost always, in most languages and most projects so I don't see any real need for supporting configuration for changing it other than thumb. Supporting such configurations aren't common in JS, and isn't needed as you may always hack the toolbar with something like: $('textarea').bind('wikiEditor-dialogs-loaded-insert-file',function(e){ //setting default for insert dialog (get by id the needed element and set it's properties) }); In such a way you can always set default for any field.
(In reply to comment #4) > kipod, thumb is used almost always, in most languages and most projects so I > don't see any real need for supporting configuration for changing it other than > thumb. > > Supporting such configurations aren't common in JS, and isn't needed as you may > always hack the toolbar with something like: > $('textarea').bind('wikiEditor-dialogs-loaded-insert-file',function(e){ > //setting default for insert dialog (get by id the needed element and set > it's properties) > }); > In such a way you can always set default for any field. Thanks for the override code snippet. My comment was meant not just for the "thumb" selection, but for all defaults. e.g., some wikis may want to define specific size as default, while others may not (Same goes for alignment). Also, please remember that as part of media wiki code, this goes not just to wikimedia-foundation wikis, but to any other wiki using the media wiki code. peace.
