Last modified: 2012-12-31 14:00:55 UTC
[ Steps to reproduce ] - Edit a page - Add §ion=new in the URL - Don't add any body message - Submit You'll get a message (missingcommenttext) "Please enter a comment below.". [ Issue ] This doesn't seem really pertinent, as section=new is used for a wider spectrum than to comment something. It's for example used to add a request on a requests page, to add a message on talk page, etc. [ Solution offered ] For missingcommenttext: "Please enter the text to add to the page below.". For editingcomment: the new section wording is fine, maybe the message title is clumsy.
Message keys are not changed. I'm not sure it makes sense not to consider that "Add a topic" (this the current name) to a discussion is the main use of section=new, and the only one offered by default by the UI. Maybe we could avoid the problem altogether (and get rid of the confusing "below") by just saying "Please enter a text for your contribution" or something like that.
