Last modified: 2013-10-16 05:42:30 UTC
Created attachment 11785 [details] Account creation See screenshot.
This is by design. As you can tell, it only does this at a certain range of smaller browser sizes, and if you go below a certain range it disappears altogether. Without one or both of those two restylings, the benefits would overlap with the form fields at small browser sizes. If you're curious be sure to also check out the section marked as "responsive styles" in the acux.css file in E3Experiments, which is currently serving these UI modifications.
(In reply to comment #1) > This is by design. As you can tell, it only does this at a certain range of > smaller browser sizes, and if you go below a certain range it disappears > altogether. It should go above, rather than below, no?
It makes more sense to have it go above if you assume most people want to read the benefits before creating an account. I'm not sure that's the case.
(In reply to comment #3) > It makes more sense to have it go above if you assume most people want to > read the benefits before creating an account. I'm not sure that's the case. Well, certainly they wouldn't want to read them *after*!
This extension is no longer deployed, and the account creation UX changes tested therein are merged in core.
It's still present in core. But per Steven's comment #1, I think it is considered a WONTFIX there. Putting it after the fold is somewhat similar to not showing it. In both cases, people are unlikely to read it. However, I think this is a reasonable trade-off on small screens, so we can show the form at the top. Putting it after the fold (rather than simply hiding it) gives them the option to scroll down even though relatively few people will.
(In reply to comment #6) > It's still present in core. But per Steven's comment #1, I think it is > considered a WONTFIX there. > > Putting it after the fold is somewhat similar to not showing it. In both > cases, people are unlikely to read it. However, I think this is a reasonable > trade-off on small screens, so we can show the form at the top. > > Putting it after the fold (rather than simply hiding it) gives them the > option > to scroll down even though relatively few people will. Yeah our desired solutions are either below the fold or not showing it. Per bug 49002 my preferred solution would be to hide it.
This is definitely not invalid, and I've seen it again just few days ago.
